AUW Investigation II
Univ’s vision in question as founder criticisedDavid Bergman
The ability of the Asian University for Women to develop into a world-class university has been impeded by the role played by its founder Kamal Ahmad, according to former members of the university’s US support foundation and senior academic staff at the university.
Although Kamal is widely applauded, even by those who criticise him, for his original vision and work in establishing the university, interviews with a wide number of people who have worked with him in the last six years suggest that in his roles as chief executive of the US support foundation and as acting vice-chancellor, he has caused the resignation of at least one acting woman vice-chancellor, the dismissal of another, and the resignation of other senior staff.
In addition, as a result of the peremptory manner in which Kamal dismissed Mary Sansalone, the third female vice-chancellor, the majority of the US support foundation board, which at that point was governing the Chittagong-based university, resigned.
A significant section of the current international faculty are also concerned that Kamal has no experience that justifies his current appointment as acting vice-chancellor.
New Age sought a response both from Professor Sheikha Abdulla Al-Misnad, the chairperson of the university’s newly established board of trustees, and Jack Meyer, the chairman of the university’s US-based support foundation, but neither replied.
Kamal also gave no specific response to detailed questions but suggested in an e-mail that New Age was ‘being fed concocted data’ and that the questions he was asked ‘mock[ed] any attempt at fair reporting.’
Despite criticisms, Kamal does continue to have support from many connected to the university and there is also praise for the educational establishment’s day-to-day teaching and activities. The trustee board is also seeking to appoint a new full-time vice-chancellor.
The disclosures about the AUW’s founder are being made at a time when wider questions are being asked about the previous
governance of the university. As reported by New Age in Sunday’s issue, for over five years, the university, which aims to be ‘the Harvard of the East’ operated without a functioning trustee board although this was the only body with legal authority to run the university.
In September 2010, the US support foundation received a report that it had commissioned from one of its own members which criticised the role played by its chief executive Kamal.
‘The CEO of the AUW support foundation,’ the report stated, ‘has unilaterally exercised the authority of the executive committee of the support foundation board on numerous occasions: at the university, this has had the effect of confusing university staff regarding who their “real boss” is: the CEO of the support foundation or the acting vice-chancellor.’
Such interference was the cause of the early departure of Hoon Eng Khoo, who had been appointed in September 2008 as acting vice-chancellor after the sudden departure of Nancy Dye, the university’s first appointment.
Although the official reason for Hoon Eng’s departure was her need to return to her tenured position at the National University of Singapore, a number of former US support foundation members have told New Age that the real reason she resigned was because of Kamal’s interference in her work.
One US support foundation member told New Age that Hoon Eng had written to its board members in December 2009 saying, ‘She was exhausted, physically and emotionally, as her authority was continually being undercut, and her decisions always subject to being second guessed, even in matters of little consequence.’
This correspondence was written just after the resignation of the dean of undergraduate studies.
The foundation member said that Hoon Eng told the board, ‘Unless there was an immediate and radical change in the way decisions were made at the university, she feared that other staff members may also leave.’
In fact, the next major resignation, three months later, was her own in February 2010 — triggered by Kamal overriding her decision to buy some digital recording devices.
The former US board told New Age that this was the straw that broke the camel’s back and that Hoon Eng told Kamal in an e-mail, ‘No vice chancellor can run the university like this.’
Hoon Eng told New Age that she did not want to talk about the reasons for her resignation nor comment on any of her correspondence with the board of the US support foundation.
The difficulties that Hoon Eng faced are reflected in the concerns held by Paul Coleman who had taken up the position of chief information officer at the university in July 2009 nine months before she resigned.
‘Mr Ahmad, whatever his due as the visionary founder of the institution, lacks the administrative skills and moral sensibility to run a liberal arts college,’ Coleman, wrote in a long letter to the US support foundation after he had left the university.
‘By increments I came to the surprising discovery that the person most responsible for the institution’s paralysis and vaguely Kafkaesque atmosphere was the chief executive of its support foundation, Kamal Ahmad — a person with no formal role in the governance or administration of the university,’ the letter, seen by New Age, went on.
‘Appropriating whimsical control over budgetary, curricular and personnel matters [Kamal Ahmad] has unaccountably blocked the purchase of essential materials and systems [and] caused the departure of numerous talented dedicated teachers and administrators,’ the letter added.
Two former US support foundation members have also confirmed to New Age their own concerns about how Kamal wielded his power as the foundation’s chief executive, particularly pointing to his difficulty in working with women.
‘It was clear that Kamal cannot work with strong women,’ one told New Age.
Another former US support foundation member said that although ‘Kamal could at one moment be very diplomatic and charming, behind the scenes he undermined any assertive female leader at the university.’
‘It is a sad and ironic thing,’ this person added, ‘that this institution is meant to be developing strong independently minded young woman leaders and yet, all that those students have seen is any strong independently minded female leader being undermined to the extent that she bears it no longer and resigns. So the wonderful vision is being undermined by actual practice on the ground.’
Following Hoon Eng’s departure, Kamal assumed the position of acting vice-chancellor and it is claimed that his ‘whimsical’ mode of management persisted.
Coleman explains in his letter to the US support foundation how surprised he was to be told by Kamal that his own contract at the university would not be renewed.
‘I had received no evaluation. I had recently been named chair of the search committee for the position of registrar,’ he wrote. ‘A few days before, Mr Ahmad had assured me that the administrative and library systems I had been recommending for months would soon be purchased. I had no reason to expect that I was about to lose my job.’
Similar concerns have been made to New Age by a number of other current and former teachers.
Mary Sansalone was then recruited to be the new provost and Kamal’s difficult relationship with women leaders seems to have continued.
‘I know the chairman of the board of US support foundation board was exhausted in just trying to keep the peace between Mary and Kamal [Ahmad],’ one former US support foundation member said.
Increasingly, members of the board of the US support foundation considered that Kamal had to go and in July 2011 appointed Sansalone as vice-chancellor.
Just over a month later, and the day after convening the Bangladesh board of advisers, Kamal managed to get himself re-appointed vice-chancellor of the university again and sent a letter to Sansalone dismissing her.
As a result of this turn of events, nine members of the board of the US support foundation resigned although new members have since been recruited.
University teachers remain angry about Sansalone’s departure, who was described by a number of them — despite a controversy over her earlier attempt to expel a dozen poor-performing students — as a ‘phenomenal leader who firmly established the AUW on a path towards academic excellence.’
New Age has also seen correspondence written by a number of different members of the university’s international teaching staff setting out criticisms of Kamal’s role as acting vice-chancellor.
A number of teachers have told New Age that they ‘expect more international faculty members will take their leave of AUW this summer and never return.’
Many current complaints focus on Kamal’s appointment of Ashok Keshari as acting provost. At a meeting in January 2012, 15 out of the 27 teachers present voted in favour of a ‘no confidence’ motion against the acting provost, with 12 abstaining. No one voted in his favour.
comments powered by Disqus
The Jatiya Sangsad on Sunday witnessed heated exchanges and subsequent expunge of ‘unparliamentary words’ as lawmakers of both ruling and opposition camps lost temper in the house on the opposition’s return after almost a year. Full story
The ability of the Asian University for Women to develop into a world-class university has been impeded by the role played by its founder Kamal Ahmad, according to former members of the university’s US support foundation and senior academic staff at the university. Full story
Investment of around Tk 5,500 crore by 59 joint ventures in the private sector approved by the government last year have come to a standstill mainly due to gas shortage and suspension of loan disbursement by the World Bank for a few of the projects. Full story
Indians living in 111 enclaves of their country in Bangladesh began an indefinite hunger strike on Sunday afternoon to press the demand for exchange of enclaves of the two countries in each other’s possession. The Indians began the hunger strike in Boda upazila of Panchagarh district in Bangladesh. Full story
The prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, again on Sunday swiped at the opposition leader Khaleda Zia allegedly for taking money from Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence ahead of the 1991 general election. ‘It’s not a report written by any paid columnist against Khaleda... Full story
Journalists announced at a grand rally in the city on Sunday that they would hold countrywide sit-in demonstrations on April 8 to press the demand for proper investigation into the recent cold blooded murders of journalist couple Sagar Sarwar and Meherun Runi in their apartments in the city and bringing the offenders to book Full story
The foreign minister, Dipu Moni, on Sunday said that the marking of 28 offshore blocks in the Bay of Bengal by the previous government was a ‘rash decision’ and such an ‘unilateral’ move without negotiations with neighbours... Full story
The prosecution on Sunday told the International Crimes Tribunal that the detained Bangladesh Jamaat-e-Islami assistant secretary general Mohammad Kamaruzzaman should be indicted as he was a top leader of Al-Badr, an auxiliary force of the Pakistani occupation army. The prosecution made the plea as it placed... Full story
The International Crimes Tribunal on Sunday adjourned the proceedings till March 20 asking the prosecution to file an application detailing its future course of action about producing witnesses in the case. The tribunal, widely known as war crimes tribunal instituted for trial of the 1971 war... Full story
Australia skipper Shane Watson saluted left-arm spinner Xavier Doherty as a game-changing slow bowler after the tourists’ 64-run win over the West Indies in their opening one-day international. Full story
Virat Kohli smashed his career best 183 runs to lead India to a six-wicket win over Pakistan and keep their hopes alive for a berth in the final of the Asia Cup in Dhaka on Sunday. Pakistan, who have two wins and a bonus points from their two... Full story
A group of citizens, including jurists, journalists, politicians, writers and educationists, on Saturday expressed concerns over the High Court’s summoning professor Asif Nazrul for giving a political analysis on a private television channel on March 12. Full story
The High Court on Sunday directed the administrators of the two Dhaka city corporations and the Dhaka Metropolitan Police commissioner to remove in 10 days all posters, banners, and structures promoting the aspirant candidates in the upcoming DCC elections. The court also asked the government to explain in two... Full story
France and the International Criminal Court have filed formal requests with Mauritania to extradite Libya’s ex-spy chief Abdullah Senussi, a security source said Sunday as Tripoli insisted that it should put him on trial. ‘For the time being two requests have been received by Mauritania. One from France arrived on Saturday and... Full story
The son of the leader of Nepal’s ruling Maoists was forced Sunday to refuse $250,000 from his father’s government for a Mount Everest expedition after the offer sparked accusations of corruption. Opposition activists had burned effigies of the prime minister, Baburam Bhattarai, and warned they would stage ‘massive’ protests across the impoverished Himalayan nation after details of the grant emerged. Full story
Confession made by former chief of Pakistan’s Inter Services Intelligence Asad Durrani does not include anything about the intelligence organisation funding BNP, claims the party’s acting secretary-general. Showing an affidavit copy of the confession the former ISI chief made before the Pakistan Supreme Court recently, Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir, told journalists that it did not include name of any individual funded... Full story
A Meteorological Department official said a light earthquake jolted parts of Bangladesh Sunday morning. Assistant director of Bangladesh Meteorological Department Shamsuddin Ahmed told the news agency that the 4.6-maginitude tremor shook buildings in the capital Dhaka at 8:56am and lasted 10 seconds. No casualties were reported immediately but many residents... Full story
The 11th anniversary of the death of poet Abu Zafar Obaidullah will be observed today. The Poet Abu Zafar Obaidullah Smriti Pathagar (memorial library) will hold a prayer session at Baherchar of Babuganj in Barisal. It also held an Obaidullah memorial fair in March 8–9. Full story
The prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, on Sunday urged India to reciprocate with the steps taken by Bangladesh for improving the relation between the two neighbouring countries. She urged for concluding the Teesta River Water Sharing... Full story